VF48Hours Forum

Forum > Posts by SF-C

Posts by SF-C

SF-C
From: Auckland
Since: May 2012
Posts: 5

2012 AUCKLAND V48 FINALISTS

Congrats to the finalists, definitely some talent in there. Good luck to you all.

I'm going to go look for the bottom of that bottle over there...

Terminal Rise
2012 - 'La Piscine Thermale' 2011 - 'Clockblocker' 2010 - 'Finding Head'
2009 - 'Divine in Convention' 2008 - 'Fight for Glory' 2007 - 'Copy Correction'
2006 - 'Brokeback Mountdoom' - Auckland Finalist
2005 - 'Disputed Epidemic'

SF-C
From: Auckland
Since: May 2012
Posts: 5

Auckland Heat 9

I would suggest instead of the current overall star rating, modify it to be like the old school reviews we used to get. Reviewers have to rate between 1-5 for story, style, use of random elements, script...or whatever. Then theoretically reviewers should be a bit fairer if they are forced to think specifically about one technical element instead of their overall feeling of a movie. But then again people will also abuse that system. You will never completely weed out the trash. It's a great site, with some dickheads souring some people's experience. In the end...you can't win em all.

Terminal Rise
2012 - 'La Piscine Thermale' 2011 - 'Clockblocker' 2010 - 'Finding Head'
2009 - 'Divine in Convention' 2008 - 'Fight for Glory' 2007 - 'Copy Correction'
2006 - 'Brokeback Mountdoom' - Auckland Finalist
2005 - 'Disputed Epidemic'

SF-C
From: Auckland
Since: May 2012
Posts: 5

Auckland Heat 9

in reply to themorgan:

I know. I realise everyone is on the 48hr buzz following the shoot weekend, and all we want is feedback, but the review site isn't necessarily where the best feedback is going to come from. Thats all I'm saying, doesn't excuse the lack of reviews though.

Terminal Rise
2012 - 'La Piscine Thermale' 2011 - 'Clockblocker' 2010 - 'Finding Head'
2009 - 'Divine in Convention' 2008 - 'Fight for Glory' 2007 - 'Copy Correction'
2006 - 'Brokeback Mountdoom' - Auckland Finalist
2005 - 'Disputed Epidemic'

SF-C
From: Auckland
Since: May 2012
Posts: 5

Auckland Heat 9

in reply to themorgan:

To be honest, most of the reviews are based purely on how the reviewers felt about the movie as one whole package. Not 'how it could have been better', or 'it did this well'. Constructive feedback isn't a priority in the reviews anymore. Which is why there is a shitstorm on some of the other threads re stars, and comments. I wouldn't worry too much about not having them. I havn't read too much into our reviews, as it's the judges, and you as a team that judge the final product constructively.

Terminal Rise
2012 - 'La Piscine Thermale' 2011 - 'Clockblocker' 2010 - 'Finding Head'
2009 - 'Divine in Convention' 2008 - 'Fight for Glory' 2007 - 'Copy Correction'
2006 - 'Brokeback Mountdoom' - Auckland Finalist
2005 - 'Disputed Epidemic'

SF-C
From: Auckland
Since: May 2012
Posts: 5

Auckland Heat 9

I remember the good ol' days when Robyn and Godfather did the Auckland reviews (were they not both associated with a certain 'F' team?). Those 2 were legends. Hard shoes to fill.

Terminal Rise
2012 - 'La Piscine Thermale' 2011 - 'Clockblocker' 2010 - 'Finding Head'
2009 - 'Divine in Convention' 2008 - 'Fight for Glory' 2007 - 'Copy Correction'
2006 - 'Brokeback Mountdoom' - Auckland Finalist
2005 - 'Disputed Epidemic'